Unit 2 Draft
A.I. Tutoring verses Human Tutoring While both AI tutoring and classic human tutoring aim to enhance learning, AI tutoring offers instant feedback, personalized pacing, and 24/7 availability, whereas human tutors provide emotional support, adaptive reasoning, and deeper contextual understanding, highlighting a balance between efficiency and empathy in education! How does tutoring from an AI differ from classic human tutoring methods? Reflections from Students at Syracuse University: Response 1: AI tutor is useful for students that need immediate help that is accessible 24/7. Since AI has no office or working hours, it can provide help when you are working on an assignment at 8 AM to 3 AM. When asking the right questions it can help me get to the answer that I need or if I am super lost know the right answer. On the downside, when the AI is not sure if something is correct, it will not say “I am not sure but this is how I would approach it” like a human would. The AI says their answ...
I really enjoyed your video. Not only is the quality and video/pictures great, but your message is powerful too. I appreciated how you didn’t just bash AI like so many others tend to do. Instead, you explored both sides—AI vs. human—and rather than declaring one as better, you explained how combining both can actually lead to even better results. Your examples and evidence really helped make that point clear. I also found it so interesting that AI can now tutor someone independently. It’s wild to think how fast technology is advancing, but you showed us that instead of being afraid, we can learn to move with it and use it as a tool to support and improve our lives. It’s refreshing to see a take that encourages balance, understanding, and adaptation instead of fear. Great job!
ReplyDelete- Katie Finnegan
I thought your video was very well made, clear, and straight to the point. You kept a good pace, and the video was under 5 minutes, which was appreciated. I heavily agree with your notion that AI is resourceful and available to your discretion at any time, but lacks the physical capability of a real person that can read a person's emotions and provide real communication/feedback. Additionally, you did a great job of complementing your voiceover with images/clips on the screen pertaining to what it was you were saying. This helped keep the video fresh all throughout, and enticing to watch. Your thesis was thought out, and the video as a whole was cohesive and concise. Overall great job- Daniel Koshchak
ReplyDeleteThis topic was very interesting to me because I have seen something like this before. There was a video of AI that had an actual voice that was going through the problems with the students step by step, as if they were actually there, while providing any guidance to make their learning experience better. It is quite scary that even tutors risk losing their jobs to these machine learning models. I thought the video was very clear, and I was able to understand the opinion on settling for the mix of both tutoring options. Lastly, it was cool to see the price difference between the two, as people give more than their time to tutor, so it makes sense they charge a little bit more. Nice job! - Ben Evans
ReplyDeleteGreat job on your project! I really liked how your video explored both sides of AI tutoring, the good and the bad. This topic is one I can relate to a lot. This year, I haven't really utilized office hours at all. I've found a way to use AI to help me learn topics I'm unfamiliar with, and sometimes, I feel like it can be more effective than having someone explain it to me, but I get that doesn't work for everyone, as your project discusses. Your video was very well put together and edited, and the pictures kept my attention throughout the whole thing. Your script was great and very informative and provided a new perspective to this topic that I haven't considered before. Overall, very well done.
ReplyDeleteTyler Katz